Bizarre tale of how a mysterious yellow submarine put a remote Scottish island in the global spotlight

Two fishermen who hauled a mysterious ‘yellow submarine’ out of the sea off Islay more than 20 years ago have recalled how the discovery propelled them to global celebrity – a story now being revived with the release of a commemorative whisky marking the 25th anniversary of Bruichladdich Distillery.

What began as a routine day creeling for lobsters off the Mull of Oa in 2005 quickly became one of the island’s most bizarre modern tales – involving military denials, international media attention and, eventually, a cult Scotch whisky.

John Baker, now 69, was working a few miles off the coast when he spotted something unusual just beneath the surface.

“At first we thought it was just a buoy or a can,” he said. “But as we got closer, you could see it was something different – something significant.”

What emerged was a bright yellow, submarine-shaped object, around 9ft long and weighing close to a tonne. With no way of lifting it aboard, Baker and his son secured a rope and began the awkward job of towing it back towards Port Ellen.

“There was no way of getting it aboard, so we got a rope on it and started towing it,” Baker said. “The weather wasn’t helping – it was hard going – but we knew we had to get it ashore and figure out what it was.

“We knew it was some kind of submersible, but we had no idea where it had come from,” he said. “It was a proper ‘what on earth is this?’ moment.”

Even on land, the mystery remained. Given the markings on the hull, the pair contacted the Ministry of Defence. The response was unexpected – it was not theirs.

Only after serial numbers were provided did the story shift, with the object eventually identified as a Royal Navy remotely operated vehicle – a mine-hunting submersible lost during exercises weeks earlier when its cable snapped. By then, however, the story had already begun to drift far beyond its origins.

With no immediate collection arranged, the submarine found its way into the garden of Harold Hastie – Baker’s brother-in-law and a local coastguard and submarine liaison officer – in Port Ellen, where it quickly became an unlikely attraction. Visitors came to see it, then came the world’s media.

“It just grew arms and legs,” Hastie, now 72, said. “What started as a local curiosity became something people were talking about all over the world.

“One minute it’s sitting there in Port Ellen, the next we’re doing interviews with everyone – every newspaper in Britain, BBC World Service, even calls from overseas,” Baker said. “It just went mad.”

The combination of a missing military asset, initial official denials and a bright yellow submarine parked in a front garden proved irresistible, and for a time, the fishermen found themselves at the centre of a story that seemed to take on a life of its own.

“It was funny more than anything,” Baker said. “The whole ‘Yellow Submarine’ thing, the Navy denying it – it just captured people’s imagination.”

“I didn’t buy a dram for three months,” he added. “Everywhere you went, people wanted to hear about it.”

The Royal Navy eventually sent HMS Blyth from Faslane to recover the submersible several months later, but by then the episode had already secured its place in Islay lore.

“It’s one of those stories that gets told again and again,” Hastie said. “And every time, people enjoy it just as much.”

placeholder image
Supplied

Few understood that better than Bruichladdich. The distillery, newly revived at the time under the stewardship of Mark Reynier and Simon Coughlin, together with legendary master distiller Jim McEwan, had built a reputation for doing things differently, and spotted an opportunity to make the most of the attention on the island.

With limited time before the submarine was returned, the team created a whisky inspired by the episode – complete with the bright yellow craft on the label. Released as part of its “Whisky of Mass Distinction” series – itself a tongue-in-cheek response to a separate military mix-up, in which the distillery was investigated by US authorities due to a faulty webcam – the bottling became one of the distillery’s most talked-about early releases.

Two decades on, Bruichladdich has brought the story back to the surface. A new limited-edition Yellow Submarine whisky has been released as part of the distillery’s 25th anniversary celebrations – a nod not just to the original bottling, but to a moment that captured something essential about Islay itself.

The whisky is a 14-year-old unpeated single malt, distilled from 100% Scottish barley and fully matured on the island in a combination of bourbon and French red wine casks.

Adam Hannett, Bruichladdich’s master blender, who took the reins from McEwan in 2015, said the new release reflects both the character of the whisky and the story behind it.

“It’s one of those whiskies that makes you smile as soon as you nose it,” he said. “It’s playful, layered and moreish – exactly what a Yellow Submarine whisky should be.”

For Baker and Hastie, while the attention has long since passed, the memory remains, particularly when visitors to the Island recount the tale in their own way, unaware they are speaking to the original protagonists.

“We had no idea what we’d found,” Baker said. “It started as a day’s fishing and turned into something that went right round the world. People everywhere have their own version, and you even hear them telling it when they come here. It’s all part of the legend now.”

In 2018, Bruichladdich acquired and restored an exact version of the yellow submarine found on eBay. It now stands proudly in the distillery courtyard – a permanent reminder of the episode.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice