Journalists and campaigners hit back at plan for freedom of information commission

More than 140 media bodies, campaign groups and others have written to the Prime Minister expressing ‘serious concern’ at the government’s approach to the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act.
Government data is regularly disclosed using requests under the FOI ActGovernment data is regularly disclosed using requests under the FOI Act
Government data is regularly disclosed using requests under the FOI Act

And the editorial board of Johnston Press, publishers of this title, are among these groups.

They are worried a new commission might turn back the clock on the public’s right to know how government operates and how public money is spent.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The Freedom of Information Act 2000 (and a Scottish Act from 2002) gave the public and journalists the right to ask questions about local authorities, the NHS, government departments, the police and many others – and they have to answer.

But the act has not been without its critics and on July 17 the Government announced a Commission on Freedom of Information.

Publishers like Johnston Press are concerned the commission is made up of politicians who are critical of the act and people who are subject to it, who are likely to restrict its remit.

Jeremy Clifford, chairman of Johnston Press editorial board said: “Johnston Press editors and journalists have used the FOI act consistently over the past decade to inform readers on many, many issues that directly affect them.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“We are deeply concerned at any plans to restrict the act and urge David Cameron to consider the membership of this commission and its remit.”

There is also concern at government plans to introduce fees for tribunal appeals when someone disagrees with a ruling by the Information Commissioner. These are currently free of charge.

The letter from publishers and campaign groups has been co-ordinated by the Campaign for Freedom of Information, a lobbying group which campaigned for several decades to have the act passed as law.

The letter says the commission’s “purpose is to consider new restrictions to the Act”.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

It points out that the Commission’s five members include two former home secretaries, a former permanent secretary and the chair of a body subject to the FOI Act.

A government perspective on the Act’s operation “will be well represented on the Commission itself” the letter says.

Among the commission members are:

Former Home Secretary Jack Straw called for information about government policy formulation to be automatically withheld, regardless of any public interest in its disclosure. Mr Straw called for charges to be introduced for FOI requests and said it should be significantly easier to refuse requests on cost grounds.

Dame Patricia Hodgson, chair of the communications regulator Ofcom. In 2012 Ofcom said “there is no doubt” the FOI Act had a “chilling effect”, discouraging the proper recording of information by public authorities. Ofcom has called for it to be made easier for authorities to refuse requests on cost grounds.

What is the Freedom of Information Act 2000?

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The Act became law in 2005 and allows public access to information held by 100,000 public authorities in the UK (Scotland is covered by a similar act from 2002).

Everyone can request official information from councils, government departments and agencies – and they have to tell you.

Public authorities of all levels are covered by the act – the police, the armed forces, regulators, the BBC, the Houses of Parliament, NHS bodies and many more.

The act does not cover personal data (that falls under the Data Protection Act) and some information is exempt. But it does allow ordinary people, journalists and campaigners the right to know how public money is spent

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Access to information helps the public make public authorities accountable for their actions and allows public debate to be better informed and more productive.

More than 400,000 information requests were made in the first ten years from the act becoming law in 2005.

Journalists in all types of newspaper routinely make FOI requests to uncover information for stories.

Some things revealed by FOI requests:

Publication of the individual mortality rates for all heart surgeons working in the NHS highlighted varying performance levels across UK hospitals.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Public sector salaries higher than £150,000 were first released under FOI - but they are now routinely published.

Prince Charles’ ‘black spider memos’ - letters to government ministers – were published after an FOI request by the Guardian.

The 2009 revelations about MPs’ expenses would not have been made available had parliamentary authorities not been preparing a heavily redacted document for FOI release (the information was later leaked to the press).

Related topics: