Celtic player ratings vs Dundee United as wasteful Hoops display sees Wilfried Nancy break unwanted 47 year record

Here’s how we rated the Celtic starting XI and subs in their 2-1 defeat to Dundee United.

In what was an absolute must-win for Wilfried Nancy, again his side paid for some early missed chances.

The Hoops should’ve been out of sight in the first half, but only went into the break a goal up through some nice forward play from Daizen Maeda. Celtic were made to pay for their early missed chances as Dundee United took the lead in the second half through Krisztian Keresztes and Zac Sapsford. In a game of two halves, The Arabs emerged victorious, meaning Nancy is the first Celtic boss since 1978 to lose four games in a row.

As Peter Lawwell announced he will be leaving the club after 18 years as Chairman, banners from Celtic support read ‘one down - more to go’ as chants against the board continued to echo around Tannadice throughout the match. Nancy made four changes from the St Mirren catastrophe, the most notable of which was Paulo Bernardo, who started in midfield for the first time in a league match since August. Elsewhere, Luke McCowan replaced AFCON bound Sebastian Tounekti in the left wing-back role.

The former Dundee man looked to be settling into his new role nicely at the ground across the road from where he made his name. His early low cross nearly found the right boot of his opposite wing-back Yang Hyun-jun, who was a whisker away from giving the Hoops the lead in the first five minutes. Another of the changes was Johnny Kenny, who came in for the injured Kelechi Iheanacho. The Irishman forced an early save from Dave Richards after he was played through by Reo Hatate, as the Dundee United defence struggled to deal with Celtic’s pace in the early stages.

After some relentless early pressure The Hoops deservedly took the lead on the 13th minute through Maeda. Auston Trusty intercepted a loose pass from the hosts. He then played a simple pass up to Kenny, who found Maeda with his pass. From there the Japanese winger left Arabs defender Keresztes for dead with his pace before slotting his left footed effort into the bottom corner. This was vintage stuff from the Celts, where had this been last week?

With the United defence playing unusually high for a Jim Goodwin side, Kenny found himself one-on-one again after a hopeful long ball from Kieran Tierney wasn’t dealt with by the United defence. However, this time he wasn’t able to get his shot away as some indecisiveness from the striker allowed Bert Esselink to get back and steal the ball from him.

The hosts had their first chance of the match that came from a long throw, then the ball landed at the feet of Keresztes. His shot was going miles wide of Kasper Schmeichel’s goal, however a deflection off of their striker Max Watters would’ve gave the Danish stopper a heart-in-mouth moment, as the ball just sailed past the post. The Hoops should’ve been out of sight in the first half as Kenny missed his third big chance of the game. This time the Irishman mistimed his shot in the six yard box from a Maeda cross.

The last time Celtic visited the city of discovery they were 2-0 down at half time but in this one, they looked comfortable. 77% possession, Maeda terrorising the United back line, defensively solid, the only thing that would’ve worried Nancy at the break is that his team weren’t four or five goals up. A flurry of early second half corners proved to Celtic why you need to take your chances in these types of games as the hosts finally worked Schmeichel, who was on alert to a Sapsford strike despite being a spectator in the first half.

It was all Dundee United at the start of the second half as they came to life and their pressure eventually paid off. Celtic failed to deal with a hopeful Will Ferry cross as captain Ross Graham kept the ball alive at the back post. The ball eventually fell at the feet of Keresztes who slotted the ball past Schmeichel. In a manic three minutes, the hosts then took the lead through a superb Sapsford curled effort from the edge of the box, causing bedlam in the Tangerine stands.

Nancy chose to switch things up as Shin Yamada, Arne Engels and James Forrest came on, cries of Martin O’Neill echoed around the stands. The former had a golden opportunity to level the game when McCowan picked him out with a cross in the 70th minute, but his left footed volley sailed over the bar. The Japanese striker had another chance five minutes later when he had the whole left hand side of Richards’ goal to aim at, but struck wide.

Maeda had a chance to equalise with an open goal in front of him, but he hit the post after Forrest found him with a cross. As both sets of fans started to sing ‘sacked in the morning’ you couldn’t help but feel for the Celtic boss whose side could’ve been out of sight of their opponents if they’d taken their chances. Expletives from Hoops fans at full time showed Nancy exactly where they stand on him keeping his job...

Here’s how we rated the Celtic starting XI and subs at Tannadice:

Kasper Schmeichel - 5/10

Was a spectator first half but was called into action early in the second to deny Sapsford. Should’ve done better with the second goal.

Anthony Ralston - 5/10

Good strong challenge on Amar Fatah in the first half when he had a shooting opportunity although as the game went on he looked increasingly shaky against the Tangerines winger.

Auston Trusty - 5/10

Interception and quick-thinking led to the opener but defensively he struggled to deal with the physicality of Watters.

Kieran Tierney - 6/10

Few good crosses in the first half that deserved a better outcome. Hooked for Liam Scales with 15 to go as his fitness continues to be a worry.

Yang Hyun-jun - 6/10

Looks to be settling into his wing-back role well and was constantly up and down the right flank.

Callum McGregor - 5/10

Not a vintage performance from the captain, who went missing at times in Tayside. Another display which suggests he’s not fully confident with Nancy’s tactics.

Paulo Bernardo - 6/10

Didn’t hide, linked up the play well and looked comfortable on his first league start in four months. Marked down for a silly yellow on Ross Graham.

Luke McCowan - 7/10

Great early cross for Yang as he settled nicely into his new role. On another day he could’ve had a few assists. Didn’t deserve to be on the losing side.

Reo Hatate - 7/10

One of the few who hasn’t dipped in form in recent weeks and maintained that level at Tannadice. Surprising that he was taken off.

Daizen Maeda - 6/10

Took his first goal very nicely and looked back to his best. Esselink hooked at half time because he couldn’t handle him. Marked down for his late sitter.

Johnny Kenny - 4/10

Should’ve had a hat-trick in the first half. His missed chances cost his team in a match that was a must-win. Wasteful.

Arne Engels - 5/10

Wasn’t able to make an impact after being dropped for the first time in seven matches.

Shin Yamada - 4/10

Skied an early chance after coming on for Kenny. Another who could’ve had multiple goals on another day.

James Forrest - 5/10

Looked lively enough after coming on. Should’ve had an assist when Maeda hit the post. Passed the ball out of play at the end which summed up Celtic’s second half.

Liam Scales and Benjamin Nygren - N/A

Neither had time to make an impact.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice