Celtic player ratings vs Hearts as red card proves damaging title blow amid positive January signing factor

Here’s how we rated the Celtic players in action against Hearts at Tynecastle.

Celtic drew 2-2 against Hearts in their latest Premiership clash

Benjamin Nygren opened the scoring in sublime fashion from a free-kick before Kasper Schmeichel made a big save to keep the title holders ahead. Yang put Celtic back in front after Stuart Findlay’s leveller early in the second half but Auston Trusty’s red card paved the way for Claudio Braga to take two points off the current champions. Celtic are six points off the top of the table Jambos but Rangers’ win over Dundee means they are now firmly in third spot.

New signings Tomas Cvancara made an immediate debut after his loan arrival from Borussia Monchengladbach as boss Martin O’Neill landed striker reinforcement ahead of a critical clash. Lose, and they’d go nine points behind the league leaders, but a win could pull them within punching distance of the Jambos. That latter reality edged closer as Nygren won a free-kick then rocketed it beyond ex-Hoops stopper Craig Gordon inside the opening 10 minutes.

The Jambos were missing key men in Lawrence Shankland, Cammy Devlin and Beni Baningime, with their visitors pouncing on that by controlling the opening stages. It frustrated the home crowd but soon Celtic would gift them a chance, Auston Trusty with a poor backpass and Schmeichel stood tall to deny Alexandros Kyziridis from close range.

Stuart Findlay would head Hearts back on level terms before Yang put the Hoops ahead again after good work from Cvancara. Auston Trusty’s red card would see the game slip away from Celtic control though as he brought down Pierre Landy Kabore in a last man tackle, and Claudio Braga levelled the game soon after. It ended a draw as Celtic failed to make a dent on their gap to Hearts and here’s how we rated the Celtic players at Tynecastle.

Kasper Schmeichel - 7/10

Two good stops in the first half, one from Kyziridis in particular. Made saves when it mattered but possibly could have done better for the first leveller. Did his part though in keeping out more.

Julian Araujo - 6/10

Kyziridis’ tricky threat was well handled even if he did get past him once or twice. No real danger from left-back either and looked to play forward.

Auston Trusty - 4/10

Limited Braga for half an hour before an inexplicable error needed a bailing out by Schmeichel. That seemed to totally set his game off as mistakes and pressure quickly ramped up from Hearts before sending off left team a man light.

Liam Scales - 7/10

Goal-saving block as Kyziridis looked to strike in the second half. Marshalled Kabore well and probably the best performer of the backline.

Kieran Tierney - 5/10

A threat in first but caught under the ball for Findlay’s leveller. Went off injured in what will be a major concern.

Callum McGregor - 6/10

Dictated the middle of the park early as skipper used extra man in midfield and experience to good use. Game turned more hustle and bustle.

Arne Engels - 4/10

A physical game that doesn’t play to his technical game and got lost at times amid the battle. Poor for the leveller and going down to 10 left him further exposed.

Benjamin Nygren - 7/10

Wonderful opener but general play again hit and miss. Some nice passes but a scrap didn’t appear like something he was too comfy with.

Yang - 7/10

McCart had him locked down and attacking was in flashes. Finally broke free and netted when it counted.

Tomas Cvancara - 7/10

Hold up and link up play was vastly improved on what Celtic have had this season. Hit the post before great play to set up Yang. Looked a handful and booked.

Daizen Maeda - 5/10

Quiet in terms of attacking output. Provided a rapid outball but that was about it.

Sebastian Tounekti - 4/10

Not much of an impact after second half substitution

Anthony Ralston - 3/10

Thrust into a chaotic defensive situation. Put under siege the entire time.

Dane Murray - 3/10

Another subbed on to find themselves with all hands to the attacking pump

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice