Celtic player ratings vs Roma: 4/10 winger struggles with new role as Italians run riot in ruthless first half display

Here’s how we rated the Celtic starting XI and subs in their heavy defeat to AS Roma in the Europa League.

In Wilfried Nancy’s first European game ever on the touchline, it should’ve been a night to remember, but it proved to be anything but.

A Liam Scales own goal in the first five minutes and Evan Ferguson brace put the game to bed in the first half. Celtic were slightly better in the second half and could’ve had a few back themselves, however a missed penalty and offside goal proved it just wasn’t their night. Roma’s 3-0 win means the Hoops are now 24th in the League Phase table.

The new Celtic boss isn’t one for changing his philosophy, as he picked the exact same starting XI as the Hearts defeat. The Frenchman’s tactics may have came under scrutiny but his passion for the club can’t be questioned as you could practically see the hairs on the back of his neck stand up as he took in ‘You’ll Never Walk Alone’ on a European night for the first time.

It didn’t take the visitors long to get off the mark when Scales found the back of his own net. The wonder left foot of Matias Soule caused Celtic problems all evening, just as he did at Ibrox six weeks ago. His dangerous corner was going towards Gianluca Mancini, but as the Irish defender tried to intervene, he headed the ball off the crossbar and into his own net. Joe Hart described the goal on TNT Sports’ commentary as ‘a brilliant header just at the wrong end’.

It was one-way traffic in the first half for Roma who were managing their lead comfortably. The visitors had a chance to double their lead when Reo Hatate was dispossessed just outside his own box by Soule. He played through Ferguson who could only find the near post with his shot. The onslaught continued five minutes later, as Niccolo Pissini’s 25-yard effort just went over the bar.

Roma’s second of the evening came courtesy of a man who grew up supporting The Hoops. Sebastian Tounekti stepped out when perhaps he should’ve held his position. This left Kieran Tierney in a two vs one situation as Soule found Zeki Celik, who played the ball into the six-yard box for the Irishman to tap-in. At this point it was looking like men against boys.

On the stroke of half-time, Ferguson struck again, after Soule found him with his back to goal. The former Brighton man was able to shrug off Scales and found the bottom corner with his shot. Moments later, The Hoops were handed a lifeline when Engels went down in the box under the challenge of Mario Hermoso. The Belgian took the penalty himself but could only strike the post, summing up a deflating first 45 for the hosts.

The second half was now just a case of playing for pride and keeping the scoreline below cricket score territory. Unsurprisingly, Nancy made changes at half time, bringing on Paulo Bernardo, Colby Donovan and Kelechi Iheanacho for Benjamin Nygren, Kieran Tierney and Daizen Maeda. However, what did come as a shock is that the shape of the team remained the same.

Iheanacho made a difference and was played in by Hatate early on in the second half. The striker was one on one with Mile Svilar between the sticks for Roma, however his shot hit the side-netting. Considering how much the Italians dominated, on another day, The Hoops easily could’ve got a few goals back.

After some early second half pressure, Celtic thought they got their goal in the 63rd minute. Hatate’s perfectly timed through ball found Engels, who played the ball to Iheanacho to tap-in, much like Fergurson’s first goal. However, VAR adjudged the Nigerian to be just ahead of the ball when it was played across. Another moment that highlights it’s just not your day.

As Celtic began to control the game, the last sight they wanted to see from the bench was World Cup winner, Paulo Dybala but the Argentinian came on as part of a Gian Piero Gasperini triple change. Former Aston Villa winger, Leon Bailey also came on and instantly made an impact, scoring a trademark left foot curler from the right hand side after some good interplay with Mancini. However, this was Celtic’s turn to have a bit of luck, as the centre back was adjudged to have been offside in the build-up by VAR.

Schmeichel made his first meaningful save of the match in the 80th minute when Bailey was played through one-on-one. The Danish stopper made himself big to stop the shot and was also equal to Paulo Dybala’s rebound. Boos rang around Celtic Park as the referee blew the final whistle as Nancy suffers a home defeat for the second game running.

Kasper Schmeichel - 5/10

Poor early distribution led to the corner for the first goal. Perhaps should’ve opted to go long more often in the first half with his team under pressure. Double save at the death bumped his score up.

Auston Trusty - 5/10

Still didn’t look comfortable on the right side of the back three but looked more assured in the second when in the middle.

Liam Scales - 5/10

The own goal didn’t look great from a defensive point of view although it was heading for Mancini anyway. Couldn’t get near to Ferguson all night.

Kieran Tierney 5/10

One of the only defenders who has experience in his role with the Scotland National Team, but still found himself out of position on numerous occasions.

Yang Hyun-jun - 6/10

Strong early tackle on Rensch set the tone as he got up and down the line well. In a team that looked at times like they didn’t know what they were doing, he stuck to his task.

Callum McGregor - 5/10

Didn’t control the game in his usual style, but came up against formidable opposition. A captain’s performance will be needed in Sunday’s League Cup final.

Arne Engels - 5/10

Was fairly quiet until he won the penalty but was unlucky to strike the inside of the post with the spot kick.

Sebastian Tounekti - 4/10

Doesn’t look as if he’s got the defensive discipline to play his new-look role. Shouldn’t have stepped out for the second goal and left Tierney helpless. Not a defender by any means.

Benjamin Nygren - 4/10

A number of attacks stopped at him in the first half and he lacked physicality. Unsurprisingly hooked at half time for Bernardo.

Reo Hatate - 6/10

Lost the ball in a dangerous area in the first half which nearly lead to a goal but showed fight after the interval. Created a few chances that should’ve been put away.

Daizen Maeda - 5/10

Worked his socks off as per usual but was eventually pocketed by Evan N’Dicka. A frustrating evening for Celtic’s talisman who received next to no service.

Colby Donovan - 5/10

After his Man of the Match performance against Feyenoord he’d have been disappointed not to start. But again, unsure if he’s suited to Nancy’s wing back role.

Paulo Bernardo - 5/10

Got his foot on the ball and relieved some of the pressure in the second half. After two lacklustre midfield performances, perhaps the Portuguese maestro could be due a start.

Kelechi Iheanacho - 5/10

Looked sharp early on considering his lengthy sideline and held up the ball well. Should’ve got a goal back on the 50 minute mark and will be disappointed he mistimed his run for the offside goal.

Anthony Ralston - 5/10

Moved into the right centre back role after coming on for Yang. Wasn’t really tested as Roma rested on their laurels at the death.

Michel-Ange Balikwisha - 5/10

On for Hatate with 15 to go. Didn’t have enough time to make a real impact.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice