Dundee send footage on Celtic incidents after controversial decisions

Celtic picked up all three points in their last Scottish Premiership outing

Dundee have sent referee chiefs footage of two incidents that they deemed to be controversial during their loss against Celtic last time out, as reported by The Courier. The Dark Blues were beaten 2-0 at Celtic Park on Wednesday night after goals by Alistair Johnston and Arne Engels.

The visitors felt Mo Sylla was fouled just before Engels added the hosts’ second during the second-half. His shirt appeared to have been pulled but it wasn’t spotted by the referee Ross Hardie.

They then believe they should have had a penalty when Liam Scales got away with a potential handball. The incident resulted in a long VAR check but a spot-kick wasn’t given.

Dundee have sent their additional footage of the two incidents to the SFA’s Key Incident Review Panel. It will be looked at next week.

Speaking after their defeat to Celtic, their boss Tony Docherty said: “I think the penalty is really soft. There’s a foul that leads up to it on Mo Sylla. I don’t know why they don’t pick that up. I’ve seen it back. Kyogo goes down and Tony’s (Antonio Portales) telling me, and I’ve seen it myself, I don’t think it’s a penalty.

“I just asked if they (the officials) checked. They said they did. But I do think there’s a strong case that it was a free-kick. There were hands on Mo’s back when he was trying to protect the ball. And I do think Antonio Portales gets a touch on the ball. So, those two things show that it shouldn’t be a penalty kick.

“We don’t [have decisions going our way]. But you know what? We’re not going to make excuses. It just seems to be sometimes it’s your turn. We’re not getting anything, even when there’s that VAR check for the penalty for handball. But I know we’re not going to get it because we don’t get them.

“So, we just need to keep working hard and showing the level of commitment that we showed tonight as a team and it’ll turn for us. There has to be a trust in the process. I’ve told the players that just keep doing that and the results will come.”

He was pleased with his team’s performance in general though and added: “I was really pleased. I thought it was a sterling effort. A really good, strong performance. It’s a difficult place to come. You’re playing against a top, top opponent. They’re a fantastic team.

“They move the ball. They get into good areas. I asked the players tonight to be resolute, to be really organised. We’d worked on a shape and to try and execute a game plan, which I think they did. So I was really proud of them. I thought the boys deserved a clean sheet for the amount of work they put in.”

Celtic are back in action this weekend with their Premier Sports Cup semi-final clash against Aberdeen on Saturday afternoon at Hampden Park. The pair are locked at the top of the Scottish Premiership.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice