The Celtic board have got it in the neck for the club's transfer business this season but how does it all stack up?
Brendan Rodgers arrived last summer and the first transfer window of his second coming has been viewed in hindsight with a degree of scepticism. Some of the stars already look destined for the exit door and one has already gone.
That summer was kicked off by a big-money sale but fans are now pleading with the club's chiefs to spend some of the cash they have inherited from Champions League participation and player sales. Celtic have also cleared some of the decks of deadwood.
January didn't add much to the tally but Celtic have still managed to conduct plenty of business both in and out of the club this season. Glasgow World rates every deal including those who have left Parkhead on loan or for good, on a scale of 1-10.

21. Sead Haksabanovic (loan exit, Stoke City) - 5/10
Out at Stoke but due back in the summer where his future will be decided. Photo: Nathan Stirk

22. Marco Tilio - 2/10
Hasn't played much and already back on loan at Melbourne City after a summer arrival. | SNS Group

23. Yang - 6/10
Impressed in flashes since coming from South Korea. | SNS Group

24. Nat Phillips - 3/10
As Celtic's centre-back options began to multiply, he was brought in from Liverpool, but struggled and now back down south. Photo: Ross MacDonald - SNS Group

