'The players aren't good enough' - Simon Jordan wades in on Celtic manager debate as he delivers damning verdict

The outspoken pundit offered his reaction to Nancy’s fourth straight defeat as Celtic manager against Dundee United at Tannadice

Loudmouth pundit Simon Jordan reckons under pressure Celtic boss Wilfried Nancy has tried to change too much too soon at Parkhead - confessing the Frenchman should have utilised the base that Martin O’Neill had built.

The former Crystal Palace chairman, who previously questioned the Hoops’ hierarchy about their process and eventual recruitment of Nancy, is of the belief that the former Columbus Crew head coach doesn’t have the respect of the Celtic dressing room.

Speaking on talkSPORT this afternoon, Jordan said: “There's an old business motto, which is ‘keep it simple stupid, kiss’ and you didn't have to do very much. You just had to perhaps utilise the basic Martin O'Neill gave you.

“I mean listen, I I like Kris Boyd a lot and obviously we spent some time with him recently up in Scotland, but I listened to such a load of old p*** last night. Some people will say we get involved arguments, right? But they're generally arguments about different ideological beliefs.

”Why they were getting involved in the Punch and Judy show I don't know, but I don't understand the point that was being made.

“Martin O'Neill did not walk on water. He is not a miracle worker. He got a group of players facing in the right direction in a sub-standard league that might have sub-standard Celtic players, but those sub-standard Celtic players are still better than most of the players in the other teams in the league that they're playing in.

“So they should be able to get outcomes and they proved the point.”

Presenter Jim White interjected by questioning whether O’Neill would have won the Dundee United game.

Jordan responded emphatically: “I think Martin would have won the majority of the games with the exception of perhaps Roma and everyone would have gone, ‘well okay, we can accept that’.”

Asked what they’ve got by appointing Nancy, Jordan went on: “I don't know. Ultimately, they've got somebody that's changed things that's come in and has a different way of approaching things, which is nothing wrong. You want managers to be definite.

Wilfried Nancy has changed too much too soon at Celtic

“But really sensible grown-up experienced managers that know what's what it's like to run big football clubs and big environments look at things and go, ‘have I got to change anything? Yeah, I want to finesse things, but should I do this over a period of time and should I do it when I've got the bodies in the building that I know will represent the values that I have?’

“I tell you what I’d do, this fella over here (Martin O’Neill) that I spent probably 15 minutes talking to when I didn't really want to that's leaving gave me a base. That base should be utilisable for me to ‘keep it simple stupid’ and then get to January and go ‘right you ain't good enough’.

“We all know that the players aren't good enough, but they're better than what they're showing. We all know that the players are culpable for these results as much as the manager are, but they'll get out from underneath because they're the poor little players, the manager takes all the flack.

“But to walk in the door and create the opportunity for... what's the context mate? The question was asked, I thought he was strong in his response and I felt well played, fair play to you when he went... you could see his temperature go up.

“But there is no context. The context that you're looking at is you've lost four games. You've walked through the door and you've had a nightmare start. You've changed things around. I don't think the players are with you, I wonder which ones are with him, wonder whether his captain is with him, wonder what's going on inside that dressing room and respond to the fact you've won seven games out of eight and go bang off a cliff. No, come on.

Brendan Rodgers culpable for ‘starting the fire’ at Celtic

“That's something that's changed in the environment. That's something that whether they're good enough... no one is disputing that Celtic could be better, and people like Brendan Rodgers are culpable for all the aggravation that is going on. They’ve started this fire with people like the board on the lack of transfer spend, and there might be some justification on it.

“But people in the boardroom walking out the door because they're getting threatened, all of this is curated by other people like Rodgers that made public statements that are not about what the football club is about. There should be more loyalty and more respect and there wasn't.”

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice