Stuart Kettlewell reveals ref verdict on controversial Dundee goal as Motherwell boss vents fury after meeting
The Motherwell boss had strong words in the wake of their Premiership loss to Dundee.
Stuart Kettlewell has vented his fury at how Motherwell controversially conceded their second goal in a 4-1 Premiership defeat to Dundee.
The game was poised at 1-1 at just over the hour mark when a corner into the home box at Dens Park saw defender Kofi Balmer go down with a head injury. Referee John Beaton didn’t bring it back and Scott Tiffoney raced up the park to score.
Lyall Cameron then added two more to make it three goals within a five-minute spell for Dundee, and confirm a third league loss on the spin for Motherwell ahead of Saturday’s game away at St Mirren.
Speaking in the aftermath of the game in Tayside, Kettlewell said Beaton decided it wasn’t a severe enough head knock. The Motherwell manager said: “One of the most bizarre games of football, especially that seven minute period in the second half that I've been involved in. Trying to recollect anything similar and I can't. I felt it was a stage where we were on the ascendancy. Obviously from our corner, I've seen several angles of it. Jordan McGhee's got his arm round Kofi Blamer's neck.
“We sat at managers meeting on Tuesday and we were told defenders on the wrong side, that type of grappling would ultimately result in a penalty kick. On his way down as he falls, he sustains a blow from the knee and the boot, the sole of the boot to his head, so it's two blows to his head as he's falling to the ground. Completely accidental, no intention in that whatsoever from the views that I've seen there. And then the counter attack results in a Dundee goal, spoken to John Beaton there, John's decided that he didn't think it was enough, a blow to the head to merit the player not moving on the ground, he never moved.
“Watch the footage back again, he lies motionless on the ground holding his head. The physio and the doctor have been on after the goal, or instantly they run on the pitch to treat him because he's got blood coming out of his mouth, but John's decided that that's not enough, a contact to his head to stop the game.
“So I take full responsibility for the third and the fourth goal, I think we're down to ten men for the third goal, Kofi's still off the pitch at that point. And in the fourth goal, we start to show way too much emotion, we start to feel sorry for ourselves, we start to feel that sense of injustice, so absolutely I take responsibility for that.
“When we know the margins are so fine in this division between teams in this league and start to get decisions going against you and the referee, and he disagrees with me as I have had a conversation with him, he gets to choose. He gets to play god.
“He decides what blow to the head is bad enough to stop the game and what’s not. I completley disagree with that and I will argue the bit with anyone. The referee doesn’t get to decide that. We were told those types of incidents would result in the referee stopping the game and he’s not done it.”
Kettlewell added: “The abuse you get, the frustration and disappointment shown from supporters. I sure as hell don’t think they were feeling that way when it was sitting at 1-1. I'll always take responsibility for the defeats, but we have to understand that again. when I sat at that meeting and I was told that we should have had a penalty and everyone agrees within the referee fraternity that we should have had a penalty at 0-0 against Ross County two weeks ago, then that changes the context of these games of football.
“Can't tell you what the end result would have been, but we know that we start to get our tail up at that moment, we know that then it becomes more difficult for the opposition to start chasing games and leaving themselves exposed, so you can understand from two of those three defeats that we face and it looks bad on the face of it, of course it does, three at the weekend, four here. You can understand the real sense of frustration that it has for me, because again it comes down to livelihoods, it comes down to jobs, it comes down to positionings in the league and all the rest of it.
“I don't think that's a difficult decision to make , I get that there's some real difficult decisions to make, but that's not a tough one . and in actual fact when we get an opportunity to look at it through VAR against Ross County as well, I'm sorry I'm going back to another incident, but when I sit there in person at that meeting I take it serious and I want to try and buy into trying to make decisions better. Willie Collum has been good that way, asking our opinion, when we all sit and see that quite clearly VAR should have given us a penalty against Ross County and when we see this incident back that we choose not to stop the game.
“I think it's a penalty, I think it's a penalty on what we discussed as managers and officials. We all agreed, defender on the wrong side, he's got his arm around the neck of the opposition player, that's probably going to mean it's a penalty. It's what we all said, if you get on the wrong side of the player then you have to ultimately grapple them in some way to try and gain that advantage back, then I'm perplexed at that one, but even take that aside, stopping the game at that moment certainly prevents Dundee's second goal.”