Furious pundit calls for John Beaton axing over 'blatant' Rangers vs Livingston handball decision amid VAR audio leak
The fallout continues after Saturday’s handball incident involving Rangers defender Emmanuel Fernandez
Marvin Bartley has outlined the VAR guidance that was passed on to referee Ross Hardie over the decision not to award Livingston a penalty against Rangers.
Danny Rohl's side were being held by the rock-bottom Lions at Ibrox when centre-back Emmanuel Fernandez blocked a close range shot from Tete Yengi with his arm.
The SFA explained that the guidance indicated that it was short proximity and that Fernandez's arm position was natural for his movement.
Now, Livi assistant boss Bartley has provided an insight into what the match officials were told on the pitch as he took aim at John Beaton, who was at the VAR controls.
Speaking on Clyde 1 Superscoreboard, he said: “There are a lot of football fans that will agree (that it's a handball) as well, if they have seen the incident. A lot of people will be alarmed that VAR didn't intervene in this situation.
“When it happened in the game we were quite far away from it. Scott Pittman appeals for it, and he is one of the most honest footballers I know, and once he appealed for it we knew something was up.
“So we watched it back and for us, it's a blatant penalty at the side of the pitch. We then speak to the fourth official and he says 'oh, we are just going to play on.'
“So, the game players out. The gaffer goes out to do the press and I manage to speak to the officials after the game and I asked them about the incident.
“I just asked them 'what was said to you guys?' and they said 'well, we were told the hand was in a natural position, and Fernandez was in close proximity to the ball when it was struck. So, there was nothing to be reviewed.'
“Anyone who has played football will tell you that's not a natural position for your left leg and your left arm to go up. The shot is definitely on target as well, so Jack Butland is going to have to pull off a save. And it's a handball.
“It’s not just because I am a coach at Livingston I am saying this. If it happens against Livingston I’m going to tell you exactly the same thing.”
Livingston coach questions VAR use in Scottish football
Bartley went on to question the use of VAR in Scottish football, deeming a potential review of the incident by the Scottish FA's head of football operations Willie Collum “pointless.”
He added: “Too many mistakes are being made. Are we putting our officials under too much pressure in using VAR? Because we are not capable of doing it.
"John Beaton is one of the best referees we do have and for him to look at that and say it doesn’t need reviewed by the referee is quite alarming for me.
“It’s happening week-in, week-out to various different clubs with different decisions. Clubs are paying big money to have VAR and we are just not capable of using it clearly. There’s no point Willie coming out and doing a review.
“If he tries to defend this I will be really surprised and I think that will agitate more people. Yes, it’s a mistake. I just don’t know how that mistake is being made.
“The fact that we are missing these things when we’re looking at a screen is the most worrying thing for our league.
“Forget about Livingston v Rangers and who it was for or against. For our league going forward that is a huge, huge worry if we cannot get something as simple as this correct.”
Ex-England cap voices opinion on ‘sackable’ offence from VAR officials
And Sky Sports pundit Jay Bothroyd has gone as far to suggest that Beaton should be sacked for failing to overturn the decision after referee Hardie didn’t blow his whistle.
Reviewing the incident on Sky‘s Ref Watch show this morning, the former England cap and Cardiff City striker said that if such an error could end up costing a manager their job, the same repercussions should be in place for match officials.
A furious Bothroyd admitted: “He is 100 per cent right. That CAN cost managers their jobs. Saying sorry afterwards means absolutely nothing because you have put someone out of a job, you have cost them a living by making a mistake like that.
“That is outrageously bad. That is terrible. You can clearly see it has not hit his body before it’s hit his hand. The ball hasn’t deviated in any kind of way, it’s not brushed off him, it’s consistently gone in the same direction and hit the player’s hand.
“That is an outrageous decision and the manager is right to feel aggrieved.”
He continued: “Decisions like that should cost the people in the VAR room their jobs. If a manager can get sacked because of a decision like that, if it was to happen, then it should be the opposite way around.
“You can’t keep making bad decisions like that because it will cost managers their livelihood and that is not fair. ‘Sorry’ afterwards is not good enough.”