Alan Shearer suspects 'unforgiving' environment will take its toll on 'stubborn' Celtic boss as 'gamble' backfires

The Newcastle United legend believes Wilfried Nancy only has himself to blame for Celtic’s struggles

English Premier League icon Alan Shearer reckons winless Celtic boss Wilfried Nancy could be just one game away from getting sacked - admitting the club’s decision to part ways with “genius” Martin O’Neill was a huge mistake.

Hoops legend O’Neill had led the Parkhead club to seven wins from eight amid a turbulent period off the pitch prior to the Frenchman’s arrival, with the former Columbus Crew head coach instantly applying his 3-4-3 football philosophy which has backfired massively.

Now staring the exit door in the face ahead of Sunday’s Premiership clash at home to Aberdeen, Nancy is firmly in must-win territory according to Newcastle United great Shearer with fans already turning on their new boss.

The former England skipper revealed he spoke with O’Neill recently and believes Celtic should have stuck by the Irishman long-term.

Speaking to Betfair, Shearer admitted: “Well, in hindsight, yes Celtic should have stuck with O’Neill over appointing Wilfried Nancy. I've spoken to Martin O'Neill and worked with Martin and his simplicity is genius. He's a great people person. He's great at putting square pegs in square holes and keeping things very simple. But I think from looking in from the outside, what Nancy has done in going in there, he's changed the system.

“It’s a similar situation to what to what is happening at Man United, I guess, that the manager has been stubborn and is not going to change after losing four out of four. He has put himself under huge pressure.

Wilfried Nancy entering last-chance saloon territory

“And it is more difficult because of what Martin did, trying to go in there on the back of what he's done. But I think as a manager, you always want to go in and try and stamp your authority straight away. But there's ways of doing that.

“Just ripping everything up that was relatively successful for seven or eight games for Martin, and then going in and completely changing the system, which he has done, was always going to be a big gamble.

“Now he's saying - I've read his quotes - saying "trust the process and we'll get it right." But it's an unforgiving place up there. And if you don't get it right pretty soon, then you know what's going to happen.

“The noise is already loud. If you don't get a win in the next one or two then you know what could happen.

“You can't have five or six defeats on the spin up there. I don't care whether you're a new manager or an old, experienced manager. That's just a no-no and it can't happen. And you know what will happen if it does.”

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice