Celtic player ratings vs Dundee United: Tayside curse continues for Hoops as they lose ground to title rivals

Here’s how we rated Martin O’Neill’s starting XI and subs in their defeat to Dundee United.

On a bobbly Tannadice surface, Celtic lost in Dundee for the third time this season in a match which could have huge title race ramifications.

On a weekend where Hearts and Rangers emerged victorious, the pressure was now on Celtic to avoid losing any title race ground. Prior to the match, Martin O’Neill had a 100% win record against the Tangerines but that was scuppered by two second half strikes from Will Ferry and Emmanuel Agyei. The 2-0 defeat means Celtic now trail Rangers by two points in the league and are five behind leaders Hearts.

Kieran Tierney has been in fine goalscoring form from defence and had the first big chance of the afternoon in Tayside. The ball fell to the feet of the Scotland International following a Celtic corner. He manoeuvred it nicely onto his left from six yards out but slightly leaning back, blazed the ball over the bar. From one left back to another, minutes later, Ferry’s powerful effort forced a smart save from Viljami Sinisalo after a rapid counter attack for the hosts.

Liam Scales can perhaps consider himself fortunate that Tierney was covering him when he tripped up Neil Farrugia after failing to deal with another United counter. Nick Walsh gave him a caution as Amar Fatah’s resulting free kick was blocked. As the game sprung into life, Celtic had a chance at the other end courtesy of Kelechi Iheanacho - on his first start since The Hoops were defeated across the road against Dundee in October. Reo Hatate’s well-weighted through ball put the Nigerian through on goal but his shot was parried out for a corner by Ashley Maynard-Brewer.

On the face of it, Celtic could perhaps consider themselves unlucky not to be ahead going into the break, but United’s defence was resolute. As the second half commenced, the players were now well aware of the challenging playing conditions. However, it was Dundee United who came out of the blocks flying as Ferry opened the scoring.

Hatate was dispossessed in midfield by Vicko Sevelj, who kickstarted the Tangerines counter. After a give and go with Max Watters, the Croatian played through Luca Stepheson bombing down the right flank. From wing back to wing back, he found Ferry at the back post with a low cross. It wasn’t a clean strike, but it was enough to beat Sinisalo and put the hosts a goal to the good.

O’Neill instantly responded to going a goal down as Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain and Sebastian Tounekti came on for Callum McGregor and Iheanacho. Minutes later, Colby Donovan had a collision with the advertising boards, ending his match prematurely. Former Dundee captain, Luke McCowan came on to the echoes of boos in an attacking change.

Hatate moved to right back in a tactical switch up and thought he may have atoned for his earlier error when he drilled the ball goal bound from the edge of the box. Maynard-Brewer failed to catch his effort as it deflected off the post as he failed to deal with it convincingly. But the United stopper fortunately managed to stop the ball crossing the line after his blunder.

Things then went from bad to worse for Celtic as Agyei doubled the hosts lead. The ball broke to The Arabs midfielder on the edge of the box, whose low effort took a nick off Scales on its way into the bottom corner. It was now a mountain to climb for The Hoops.

Sevelj nearly put the game out sight for Dundee United as he got on the end of a Ferry cross, but Sinisalo was well positioned to deal with it. Iurie Iovu then had a chance from a corner that went just over the crossbar. If anyone looked like scoring the next goal it was the hosts.

Daizen Maeda had a fairly quiet afternoon but he was inches from getting a goal back for Celtic when he tried to prod the ball past Maynard-Brewer from point blank range. Somehow, the United stopper got a fingertip to it but referee Walsh didn’t see it and gave a goal kick. That would be Celtic’s last chance of the game as they tasted defeat on Tayside for the third time this season. Next up, after the International break is a trip to Dens Park.

Here’s how we rated the Celtic starting XI and subs:

Viljami Sinisalo - 6/10

Very good early save from Ferry’s effort. Helpless for both goals. Parried a late free kick which he should’ve caught.

Colby Donovan - 6/10

Got stuck in. Looked shaky at times but held his own for large parts. A collision with the advertising boards cut his match short as he was replaced by Luke McCowan.

Benjamin Arthur - 6/10

Another assured display from the Brentford loanee, who looked comfortable enough given the conditions. May still keep Auston Trusty out of the team.

Liam Scales - 5/10

Early caution left him walking on eggshells. Didn’t always look comfortable against Max Watters. Didn’t come across as a leader at the back.

Kieran Tierney - 6/10

Should’ve opened the scoring given his recent form. Offered attacking threat but wasn’t as resolute defensively compared to recent performances.

Callum McGregor (C) - 6/10

Swept up well when the ball broke and controlled the play well in the first half. Must be still carrying a knock as he was hooked for Oxlade Chamberlain around the hour mark.

Reo Hatate - 6/10

A great ball to Iheanacho almost led to the deadlock being broken but then lost the ball for the United opener. Moved to right back after Donovan’s injury. Hooked for Junior Adamu on the 75th minute.

Benjamin Nygren - 4/10

Drifted into some nice areas but equally struggled with the surface when on the ball. Misplaced a few passes on what a frustrating afternoon for Celtic’s top scorer. Hooked for James Forrest on the 75th minute but could’ve been earlier.

Yang Hyun-jun - 5/10

Done his usual but offered very little in terms of attacking quality. He was an out ball on the break but very little other than that.

Daizen Maeda - 5/10

Back in his preferred position out wide. Done his usual relentless press but was ineffective in attack. Didn’t have a great deal of service. Should’ve got a goal back.

Kelechi Iheanacho - 5/10

Put himself about on his first start in three months. Couldn’t have done much more with his early effort. Hooked for Tounekti just before the hour mark.

Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain - 5/10

The experienced campaigner struggled to get to grips with the surface after being brought on with half an hour to go.

Sebastian Tounekti - 4/10

Celtic’s resident super-sub wasn’t able to have his normal impact. Kept quiet by a resolute United defence.

Luke McCowan - 5/10

A free kick blasted straight into the wall at the death was his only contribution against his old enemy.

James Forrest and Junior Adamu - N/A

Didn’t have time to make an impact.

The Scottish Football Social Club is presented by BetSBK.com | 18+ | Gamble Responsibly

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice