Celtic player ratings vs Livingston: Dream debut for new signing as last minute screamer spares Hoops blushes

Here’s how we rated the Celtic starting XI and subs in their dramatic late victory over Livingston.

Celtic kept pace with their title race rivals Hearts and gain two points on Rangers with a victory over bottom of the table Livingston in the SPFL Premiership, however it was far from routine.

Marcelo Saracchi came into the starting XI for Kieran Tierney and made an immediate impact as his long range effort from a corner found the back of the net. What followed was a potential huge blow as Arne Engels went off holding his thigh after going down unchallenged. Celtic rued some early missed chances at the start of the second half when Robbie Muirhead equalised from the spot. Just as the visitors thought they’d done enough to secure a point, up stepped substitute Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain with a 90th minute screamer on his Celtic debut.

The Celtic boss said he regretted making too many changes in their Dundee Scottish Cup scare, therefore wasn’t downing any tools for this one despite the poor form of their opponents. Along with Saracchi, Kasper Schmeichel, Arne Engels, Benjamin Nygren, Daizen Maeda and Sebastian Tounekti all reclaimed their places in the starting XI.

Within the first five minutes, Jerome Prior was already forced into making three saves, setting the tone for the match. Firstly, the Livi keeper was equal to Callum McGregor’s effort from the edge of the box. He then saved a close range strike from Daizen Maeda and came out on top as Tomas Cvancara went through on goal. The opening stages gave the impression the game was going to be one-way traffic, however the visitors also showed some attacking intent when Kasper Schmeichel made an early save from Stevie May’s strike from inside the box from a Danny Wilson flick on.

After that, the Celtic onslaught continued with Livingston hanging on by a thread as Prior made six saves within the first 15 minutes. The french stopper made a tremendous double save when he parried Benjamin Nygren’s edge of the box effort into the feet of Maeda, who he then got up quickly to shut out again. Once again the ball ricocheted back to the Japanese winger, but at his second bite of the cherry he fluffed his shot.

The relentless pressure from the hosts eventually paid off from a simple corner routine as Livi failed to clear an Engels corner that reached Saracchi on the edge of the box, who rifled the ball past Prior, who this time was rooted to his spot. Even though it was only 1-0 there were early signs it could be a cricket score.

On the half hour mark, there was a major blow for Martin O’Neill as the assister went down injured unchallenged and was forced to come off. Engels is clearly a player the veteran coach sees something in, having rejected Nottingham Forest’s £25m bid for him in the transfer window. Reo Hatate was the man to enter the field of play earlier than expected.

The chances dried up slightly towards the end of the first half, in which the visitors miraculously only conceded once. Celtic had 17 shots at goal with 10 of them on target, O’Neill would be asking for more attacking cutting edge from his side after the break.

The second half started in a similar fashion to the first with a flurry of Celtic chances. Liam Scales should arguably have done better with his free header in the six yard box from a Tounekti cross, which the Irishman blazed over the bar. Cvancara was then millimetres from getting on the end of Hatate’s low cross after he was played in by a fantastic ball from Saracchi.

Disaster then struck for The Hoops in the 55th minute when Hatate missed the ball in his own box and kicked Robbie Muirhead instead. The Livi striker then stepped up to take the spot kick he won and placed it straight down the middle as Schmeichel dived to his left, giving the visitors a miraculous equaliser. A stern reminder for The Hoops that you must take your chances in the Premiership regardless of the opposition.

Tierney and Dundee hero Junior Adamu were brought on almost instantly to try and swing the match back in Celtic’s favour, however as the game wore on Parkhead became more and more agitated. Similar to the first half, the chances dried up with about 15 minutes go. In O’Neill’s final role of the dice, ‘The Ox’ was brought on for his debut in place of Maeda, while veteran James Forrest came on for Julian Araujo.

Livingston, who are on a 24-match winless run, were defending for their lives at the death with Celtic struggling to create any clear cut chances. With six minutes added on, there was time for a hero to emerge like Adamu did on Saturday afternoon and the new boy Oxlade-Chamberlain did just that, with a sublime finish. Tounekti found himself on the left hand side and found the former Arsenal man on the edge of the box, who curled the ball past Prior, allowing Hoops fans to breathe a sigh of relief.

Kasper Schmeichel - 7/10

Forced into to an unexpected early save from May where he showed superb reactions. Tried his usual mind games for the penalty to no avail.

Julian Araujo - 7/10

A real attacking threat for The Hoops, whose natural playing style helps keep a high tempo. Another impressive display from the Bournemouth loanee.

Auston Trusty - 7/10

He’ll have a lot more challenging days at the office. But looked solid enough when called upon.

Liam Scales - 6/10

Again very rarely tested. Look assured enough but marked down for a needless yellow card on the stroke of half time. Should’ve troubled the goalkeeper with his second half header.

Marcelo Saracchi - 8/10

Looked sharp on his first start in over two months. A great long range effort for the goal and a constant attacking threat.

Callum McGregor - 5/10

Booked for a professional foul on May. Not a vintage performance from the captain but the result is all that mattered.

Arne Engels - 6/10

His corner led to the Saracchi opener, but his early injury didn’t allow him to make a further impact on the game. Hoops fans will be hoping it’s not as bad as first feared.

Benjamin Nygren - 7/10

He usually loves a goal against Livi having scored two braces against them so far this season. Not on the scoresheet this time around but a constant attacking threat nonetheless.

Sebastian Tounekti - 7/10

Changed the game on Saturday and once again got a late assist. Was a thorn in the side of the Livingston defence all night.

Daizen Maeda - 6/10

Looked even more lively than normal after his Scottish Cup rest. Put in a few good crosses that his teammates should’ve put away but also should’ve got amongst the goals himself.

Tomas Cvancara - 5/10

Should’ve scored early on and subsequently failed to get into the scoring positions despite the early pressure. Hooked for Adamu on the hour mark.

Reo Hatate - 5/10

Called upon earlier than expected after Engels’ injury. Pure carelessness to give away the penalty when Celtic were in the ascendancy.

Junior Adamu - 5/10

Subbed on around the hour mark to emulate his Dundee heroics. Didn’t have the same impact.

Kieran Tierney - 5/10

Practically a winger as Celtic chased a winner. Brought onto help manage the minutes of the returning Saracchi.

Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain - 8/10

Came on to an ovation for his Hoops debut. Couldn’t have asked for a better start to his Hoops career. His superb strike shows you never lose it.

James Forrest - 6/10

Struggled to make an impact in his 10 minute cameo. Put in a few half-decent crosses but nothing ground-breaking.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice