Celtic player ratings vs Utrecht as 19-minute demolition job and Hoops flop gift extends Europa League run

Celtic progressed in the Europa League with a battering of Utrecht.

Celtic have reached the knockout round play-offs in the Europa League with a 4-2 win against Utrecht.

Three goals in 19 devastating minutes all but sealed progress out of the league phase in a game Martin O’Neill’s side had to win. Utrecht got a goal back before the break and netted again after it before Auston Trusty’s second half header calmed rising nerves. They will take to the next round of the Europa League in February but next up in the Premiership is Falkirk.

Amid fierce criticisms of the board for a lack of transfer business and sitting third in the league, elimination from Europe would only pile on to negative feelings around Parkhead. The return of O’Neill has been a beacon of hope for fans and the manager of the Celtic side that made the UEFA Cup final in 2003 was about to bring a much-needed night of relief.

For the first time in their history, they blasted home three inside 20 first half minutes. A short corner caught team 35 out of 36 in the league phase napping, Kieran Tierney squaring the ball to Benjamin Nygren for a tap-in. Some fans feared Vasilis Barkas, the goalkeeper who flopped at Parkhead during the infamous Covid season, would be back to haunt them on the continent but he instead passed a poor ball straight into the path of Nygren. The Swede’s cutback was bundled into the net by Nick Viergever and before the clock hit 20, VAR had judged Utrecht’s Dani De Wit to have handled the ball inside his box.

Arne Engels stepped up and blasted home from 12 yards to leave the game done as a competitive contest and progress to the next round sealed. This was a thumping if Celtic wanted it to be but some slackness crept in and allowed Dani De Wit to get one back, with Kasper Schmeichel making a big save to deny Utrecht another. Schmeichel perhaps could have done better in the second as Adrian Blake fired low into the corner, but Trusty’s header sealed progress.

There are bigger picture issues to be wrestled and the noise over the transfer window will not cease, in fact it will get louder the longer no further business is conducted. That said, for 90 minutes at Parkhead, a European win was had and a ceasefire of sorts was called despite hostilities between fans and board that aren’t going away anytime soon. Here’s how we rated the Celtic players.

Kasper Schmeichel - 5/10

Pretty much a spectator for most of the night but big save at end of first half. Has to save Blake’s effort amid continued criticism of his performances.

Colby Donovan - 8/10

Basically creates the opener with quick thinking, attacked well and defended brilliantly. Coming into his own.

Auston Trusty - 8/10

Passing out from the back was good and not troubled in a defensive sense. Comfortable and controlled while creating penalty situation and then headed vital goal.

Liam Scales - 7/10

Some excellent headers and very comfortable on the ball. Continues to grow into leader role at the back.

Kieran Tierney - 8/10

A rampaging night. Got an assist and kept popping up in inverted positions, causing havoc. One of his best since returning.

Callum McGregor - 7/10

Dictated play and Utrecht couldn’t find a way to stop him from setting the Celtic tone.

Arne Engels - 7/10

Scored the penalty and more comfortable nature of game allowed more time to show his technical flair. Goal for Utrecht comes partly with his lack of challenge but then a pinpoint corner ends game. Confusing player.

Benjamin Nygren - 8/10

Is he finally beginning to win over Celtic fans? Another goal here and helps put the tin lid on an error by Barkas.

Sebastian Tounekti - 5/10

Frustrating night. Should have scored with game at 3-0 and his lapse of concentration allows Utrecht in to score. Not enough going forward and left Tierney exposed at times.

Daizen Maeda - 5/10

Plenty of running but wasn’t involved in too many clear cut opportunities.

Yang - 6/10

Some nice touches and endeavour before booking seemed to clamp his game a touch.

Kelechi Iheanacho - 3/10

Biggest thing is minutes on the pitch after injury.

James Forrest - 3/10

Handed just over 20 minutes near the end.

Paulo Bernardo - N/A

Late cameo for the midfielder.

Luke McCowan - N/A

Another who cameoed late.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice