Martin O’Neill warned he risks damaging legacy and becoming Celtic ‘villain’ as growing concern laid bare
Former Parkhead winger delivers frank assessment of Celtic's struggles while warning O'Neill about the dangers of staying too long
Former Celtic winger Aiden McGeady believes Martin O'Neill will be keen to avoid staying at Parkhead long enough to see his standing among supporters damaged, as questions continue to grow over the veteran manager's future.
The 74-year-old returned to Parkhead last season and delivered a domestic double against the odds, restoring stability and further enhancing his already impressive reputation at the club.
However, his current spell in charge has brought fresh criticism, with uncertainty surrounding his contract situation, inconsistent performances in key fixtures and growing frustration among large sections of the fanbase.


McGeady believes the Northern Irishman has plenty of credit in the bank following last season's achievements, but admits there is a question over whether walking away after that success might have been the perfect way to preserve his legacy.
Speaking about O'Neill's situation, the former Celtic favourite told Casinostugan: “It's normal for questions to be asked, especially with Martin O'Neill's contract situation. The phrase goes: 'You live long enough to become the villain,' don't you?
“After winning the double at the end of last season, Martin O'Neill's legacy couldn't have been bigger, but sometimes you wonder if that was the right time to walk away.
“Beyond the manager, there's a broader disconnect between the fans and the board right now that's adding to the tension. But they are still in with a chance of several trophies, there is still time to turn that feeling around.”
McGeady identifies Celtic's biggest concern
While Celtic remain in contention for domestic honours this term, McGeady believes their performances against stronger opposition have exposed a problem that O'Neill needs to address urgently.
The former Republic of Ireland international is particularly concerned by their struggles against Rangers and in European competition.
Although Celtic have continued to collect victories in the Premiership, McGeady feels the quality of their football has dipped.
He admitted: “Celtic will be fine domestically overall, but in the big games, against Rangers and in Europe, they've fallen short. That's the big concern. Apart from the Rangers and Falkirk games, Celtic have won pretty much every domestic game. But at some point you need to see a change in performance quality.
“The free-flowing attacking football isn't quite there right now. Earlier in the season they were winning convincingly, now they're scraping wins, which leads to questions being asked of the team and the manager.”
Rangers have given Celtic a genuine title fight
McGeady also believes the Premiership could be heading towards one of its closest title finishes in recent years, with Rangers currently showing signs of improvement under Derek McInnes.


Celtic remain in the driving seat, but their Glasgow rivals have gained considerable belief from their recent victories over the Hoops.
Rangers have endured a difficult period in the battle for domestic supremacy, having won just one league title in the past 15 seasons. However, McGeady believes there is a different feeling around the Ibrox side this time, with their recent results providing evidence that they can sustain a serious challenge.
“This season could be the closest title race we've seen in a while,” he declared. “In previous years outside of the COVID season, Celtic were by far the better team. But Rangers are improving and took a lot of belief from their two wins over Celtic recently.
“Celtic are still winning, but Rangers are right there with them, they've only won one title in 15 seasons but they do look stronger this time out. Celtic are still top, but it will be those games against Rangers towards the end of the season that decide where the title goes this season.”
*The Scottish Football Social Club is presented by BetSBK.com | 18+ | Gamble Responsibly