Ally McCoist in savage takedown of Rangers transfer failings as Ibrox hero delivers brutal truth after duo's sacking

Rangers hero didn’t hold back in his criticism of his old club’s ‘appalling’ recruitment as he reacted to the dismissal of Kevin Thelwell and Patrick Stewart

Rangers legend Ally McCoist claims the sackings of Patrick Stewart and Kevin Thelwell was inevitable after soe “appalling” recruitment - insisting it shows the club’s new American owners will stop at nothing to bring success back to Ibrox.

Chairman Andrew Cavenagh took the decision on Monday to part company with both CEO Stewart and sporting director Thelwell who had become major targets for furious supporters in recent weeks. And after various protests, a large section of fans finally got their wish in the removal of both figureheads.

McCoist - the Light Blues all-time leading goal scorer - expressed his dissatisfaction with their shambolic transfer dealings and declared the duo’s sudden exit came as no surprise to him.

Thelwell, whose son Robbie was recently hired and remains as head of recruitment for the time being, set out on a £20 million net spend, with the majority of players brought in over the summer proving inferior to those who were released at the end of last season.

‘Not poor, not bad. Appalling’

Coisty said: “The departures of Patrick Stewart and Kevin Thelwell are not a shock, not a surprise. I've been constant with this all along, the recruitment has been appalling, really. It has been appalling. Not poor, not bad. Appalling.

“We have signed players this year, and not one of them has been better than any of the players we have let go. So that's one of the reasons that we are where we are.

“We've signed one or two centre-backs, neither of them are as good as Leon Balogun. We've played a couple of boys at left-back, none of them are as good as Ridvan Yilmaz or Jefte.

“We signed the big boy up front, Youssef Chermiti, who will not score as many goals as Cyriel Dessers or Hamza Igamane. Djeidi Gassama has played well, by the way. And he's without doubt, in my opinion, probably the best signing that we've made. However, he isn't any better than Vaclav Cerny.

“So, when you put it like that, in layman's terms, it's pretty straightforward. You're signing players that aren't as good as the players you're letting go. Now that can only be a recipe for one thing, and it isn't success.

“It is not success. Look at the centre-backs, we had Conor Goldson and Balogun, solid boys, boys that went to the European final. You had Alfredo Morelos up front, you had Ryan Kent.

“These are good, good players that are miles better than we've got at this moment in time. So the recruitment has to stand up and be scrutinised and accounted for. And it hasn't been good enough.

“So the decision effectively isn't a surprise. I believe what will happen is, I would expect the management or the ownership to to probably say that fan protest wasn't the be-all and end-all their decision due to the fans, but you also have to listen to the fans.

“You have to listen to the fans, and I thought personally there was too much water under the bridge for them to survive, and I think that it's no major surprise to me that it's happened.”

McCoist reckons the bold decision to fire both men at the same time outlines Cavenagh and the 49ers Enterprises ruthless streak. He told talkSPORT Bet: “The owners have maybe got a little bit of a shock at the reaction from the fans, media, and everybody. What they're like is different. They are completely different.

“And the businessmen that have come in to take over the club, I think they're showing they're to be ruthless, right? They've shown they'll be ruthless and they won't stop in pursuit of excellence and take Rangers back to a level where they should be and where they belong.

“I for one don't mind that. There'll be a few decisions that will get made that people will not agree with. But if they're done solely in people's belief that they're in the best interest of the club, I can live with that.”

Rangers draw against Braga would be a positive outcome

Rangers currently sit rock-bottom of the 36-team Europa League table after losing all four games so far ahead of facing Portuguese side Braga at home on Thursday night. The visitors already claimed a win on the other side of Glasgow against Celtic in the same competition.

And McCoist identified a lack of creativity in the forward areas as Rangers main issue, citing the departures of several key players as a reason behind their current struggles. He suggests a first point on the board would signal a step in the right direction.

McCoist said: “It's tough. I watched them get outplayed by the Italians in the last game against Roma. In the last game they could have won two-nothing. I just looked at the Italians and saw they could have gone up another gear, really could have.

“Rangers lack creativity in forward areas. As I say, we've lost Vaclav Cerny, we've lost Hamza Igamane, we've lost Cyriel Dessers. That's well over 60 goals out of your team, and you've not replaced them.

“So if Rangers can get a draw against Braga, I think that would be a step in the right direction, and I would take a one-each right now.”

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice