Adam Tomkins

Glasgow City Council’s depute leader slams online trolls over Rangers FC fan zon...

Both campaigns have used hope arguments and fear arguments, according to Better Together campaigner Professor Adam Tomkins.

Why did Better Together name campaign Project Fear?

A productive economy in an independent Scotland will create much more tax simply because it will make workers wealthier, according to Robin McAlpine.

Where will Yes campaign find the money for pensions?

Defence has been at the heart of the debate and Professor Adam Tomkins is urging readers to investigate the issue further before casting their vote.

No campaign’s view on defence and foreign policies?

Find out why Robin McAlpine from the Yes campaign thinks women are, quite literally, worth their weight in oil in the workforce

Where are jobs promised to women by Yes coming from?

According to Professor Adam Tomkins, there are very sound reasons for not having a currency union which he invites readers to explore further.

No camp: What happens to UK credit rating if it’s Yes?

Why would Scotland be better separated from the Union? There are so many reasons, according to Robin McAlpine - a few of which he shares with readers.

Why does Yes campaign think separation is better?

Delivering the No campaign's Better Together message at the Gazette's Independence Debate in May, Professor Adam Tomkins

When will Better Together agree powers for Scotland?

Why should the Scottish people believe more powers will be forthcoming in the event of a No vote? Robin McAlpine and Professor Adam Tomkins answer the final question posed to both campaigns.

Truth of oil wealth hidden? Yes or No – You Decide

What assurances can the Yes and No campaigns give to farmers? Find out, as Robin McAlpine and Professor Adam Tomkins tackle this reader's question.

Farming industry protected? Yes or No – You Decide

Is Scotland not more than capable of looking after itself? Robin McAlpine and Professor Adam Tomkins answer this question, posed by a Gazette reader

Scotland financially stable? Yes or No – You Decide

Why does the UK want to retain Scotland? Robin McAlpine and Professor Adam Tomkins reveal the main reasons, as they see it

Why UK wants Scotland to stay: Yes or No – You Decide

Is the pound not Scotland's too? Robin McAlpine and Professor Adam Tomkins share their views on this question, posed by a Gazette reader

Is pound not Scotland’s too? Yes or No – You Decide

Has Scotland lost out on jobs? Find out what Robin McAlpine and Professor Adam Tomkins views are on this question posed by a Gazette reader.

Jobs lost in Scotland? Yes or No – You Decide

World War One...reader asks Robin McAlpine and Professor Adam Tomkins if the commemoration of the Great War was in fact a ploy to detract from Scotland's year

Commemoration a ploy? Yes or No - You Decide

Head to head: Robin McAlpine and Professor Adam Tomkins go toe to toe on pensions

Pensions: Yes or No – You Decide

Memorial Hall...was packed for the Carluke and Lanark Gazette Scottish Independence Debate (Pic Rodger Price)

Gazette Independence Debate, May 26, 2014, Slideshow

Better Together...said Clydesdale MP David Mundell at the Carluke and Lanark Gazette Scottish Independence Debate in Lanark Memorial Hall on Monday, May 26, 2014 (Pic Rodger Price)

Gazette Indy Debate - MP David Mundell: Better Together

Vote Yes...said Clydesdale MSP Aileen Campbell at the Carluke and Lanark Gazette Scottish Independence Debate in Lanark Memorial Hall on Monday, May 26, 2014 (Pic Rodger Price)

Gazette Indy Debate – Aileen Campbell: Yes Clydesdale

Better Together...said Professor Adam Tomkins at the Carluke and Lanark Gazette Scottish Independence Debate in Lanark Memorial Hall on Monday, May 26 (Pic Rodger Price)

Gazette Indy Debate – Adam Tomkins: Better Together

Passionate speaker...Robin McAlpine at Lanark Memorial Hall (Pic Rodger Price)

Robin McAlpine backs Yes vote

Independence Debate: David Mundell’s argument - video

Independence Debate: Professor Adam Tomkins’ argument - video