Alternate Celtic XI that could be deployed vs Stuttgart as Old Firm factor sees eight changes and shock starts

Here’s an alternative look at how Martin O’Neill could set up his side in Germany for their Europa League knockout tie.

After their 4-1 defeat at Celtic Park last weekend and a mammoth fixture against Rangers on the horizon, Martin O’Neill is in a situation where he may be forced to make wholesale changes for a European knockout match.

In a match where there were problems for Celtic on and off the park, a Bilal El Khannous brace, Jamie Leweling strike and Tiago Tomas finisher gave Stuttgart a thumping win which leaves them nigh on out sight against Celtic, who have a mountain to climb in Thursday’s away leg. After things went from bad to worse at Celtic Park in their first home defeat to Hibs in 16 years, they now have an Old Firm Derby this Sunday which is nearing the ‘must-win’ category, leaving the manager in a tough spot regarding his team selection for the Stuttgart tie.

Given the heavy nature of the Stuttgart defeat, O’Neill may well have one eye on the Rangers fixture and rest a few big name players so they’re fresh for Ibrox, however, the Hoops boss also can’t afford another hammering which could risk knocking the confidence of his relatively young squad. In a match where there’s a fine line between resting star players and avoiding embarrassment, here’s an alternative line up O’Neill could go with on Thursday night:

Viljami Sinisalo

Kasper Schmeichel had a well-documented nightmare in the first leg with many Hoops fans now agreeing the back-up deserves his chance. In a match where he’ll be tested far more than in his previous Scottish Cup appearances, it’d be a good chance for O’Neill to see if he can step up to the plate.

Colby Donovan

The young defender has had some huge performances already in the Europa League this season. While still being a bit raw and not possessing the same attacking quality as Julian Araujo, he doesn’t play with fear which could be handy in a fixture like Thursday night.

Auston Trusty

While he’ll be unavailable for the next three league matches, O’Neill may still play one of his more experiencd defenders to prevent further embarrassment. Although don’t be surprised to see an early sub.

Dane Murray

Someone is going to have to replace Trusty against Rangers, Aberdeen and Motherwell. If it’s the young defender, then a run out against the Germans would give him a good opportunity to get some valuable match fitness.

Marcelo Saracchi

He’s been unfortunate with injuries and has shown quality at times when fit both defensively and offensively. Kieran Tierney is nigh on essential for the Old Firm and with a capable replacement, he could be one that’s rested.

Callum McGregor

Regardless of the situation, the captain plays every game between now and the end of the season if fit. Another who’ll have a big part to play on Thursday night.

Luke McCowan

Came on as a sub in the previous leg and remarkably has only started once under O’Neill, against Auchinleck Talbot. With in-form Benjamin Nygren one of the players likely to be rested for Sunday, McCowan offers less attacking threat but will do more work off the ball.

Paulo Bernardo

A surprise inclusion in the first leg, showing how depleted Celtic are in numbers in the European squad, with Arne Engels injured and Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain ineligible. Like McCowan, his only full 90 under O’Neill came against Talbot.

James Forrest

While Daizen Maeda seems to have an unlimited source of energy, Celtic’s Duracell bunny will need to be recharged at some point. If the experienced Forrest starts then the Japanese star will be good to go for the all-important Old Firm Derby.

Sebastian Tounekti

If Celtic have any glimmer of hope of pulling off a miracle at the MHP Arena, then the Tunisian is their only hope, although he’ll be another they’ll need to keep fit for Sunday. A starter then subbed after an hour perhaps?

Junior Adamu

Hasn’t really shone since his heroics against Dundee in the Scottish Cup although his pace and power could cause problems for the Stuttgart defence, who despite their attacking prowess, have shown they’re susceptible to conceding goals in recent weeks.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice