Paul Tisdale walking Celtic tightrope as Hoops icon left questioning his position if beleaguered boss Nancy is axed
Chris Sutton explains why Celtic’s recruitment chief should be shown the door if club officials decide to wield axe on Nancy
Chris Sutton has led calls for Paul Tisdale to leave his role as Celtic’s head of football operations IF beleaguered boss Wilfried Nancy is sacked.
The former Columbus Crew head coach is under intense pressure just four games into his Parkhead tenure after losing to Hearts, AS Roma, St Mirren and Dundee United in the last fortnight.
Writing in his Daily Record column, Sutton said: “I genuinely cannot quite believe I’m saying this after just four matches in charge - if Wilfried Nancy makes it five in a row against Aberdeen, his position will be untenable.
“That sounds slightly ridiculous and it gives me no pleasure in saying it. People outside of Scotland cannot get their heads around it but this is the reality in Glasgow. Celtic managers have to win games - simple as that.
“It has been a disastrous start for the Frenchman and the problem has already got to a stage where you have to wonder how long it can go on. How much damage could it do to the season if action is not taken?
“People talk about getting his own signings in but has Nancy shown enough that he can be trusted with the January transfer window? Will he even last until the window opens? We know he has his own style and formation, so do you let him attempt to buy in the players who suit... only for it to keep going wrong and then whoever is next is left with a team built to play one way?
“These are all things that have to be taken into consideration by the board. Then again, can they be trusted to make the right calls when they keep making poor ones? I’ve got a lot of sympathy for Nancy. He was on a hiding to nothing coming in with a backdrop of unrest and then following club legend Martin O’Neill, who managed to paper over the cracks.
“To land during a brutally tough run of fixtures was always going to be a huge challenge with the squad he has at his disposal. It’s proved to be disastrous. I’ve said it repeatedly - this is the chickens coming home to roost for Celtic and they are now paying the price for the woeful summer transfer window.
“This is a bang average squad lacking in quality and missing some very important players. You only have to look at the strike problems for starters. No harm to Johnny Kenny, he’s a young lad who wasn’t expected to be in this position at this stage of his Celtic career. But he wouldn’t be leading the line for most of the other top-six sides in the Premiership.
“And what does that say about Shin Yamada? You can maybe forgive him for being a little rusty due to a lack of game time but the opportunities he missed at Tannadice on Wednesday only suggest he’s not going to cut it.
“Kelechi Iheanacho has been a top player but it’s hardly a surprise he’s not been able to stay fit given his lack of game time in the last year or so. There’s no point going back over old ground with the wide players but we know they are not contributing anywhere near enough.
“Even so, Celtic missed enough chances to be out of sight in the first half against Dundee United but didn't’ have the quality to finish it. The second half was shocking. And there’s already a pattern here, with heart tweaking things at half-time and seeing it out, St Mirren doing the same and now United.
“Nancy hasn’t helped himself, though, with his tactics or his comments. Changing so much so soon was either bold or stupid. He either misjudged the squad he inherited or the level of opposition. Even three nights ago, playing one recognised centre-back against a team who are strong at set-pieces was bizarre.
Paul Tisdale must also be sent packing is Nancy is shown the door
“Saying Celtic played well at United will not cut it... neither will talking about knowing the Scottish game because he nearly signed for Carlisle... or getting involved with social media. All of this is just adding pressure to an already combustible situation.
“A lot of supporters have already made up their minds. There were chants for O’Neill and also against Nancy at Tannadice. It’s not something that sits comfortable with me. It’s the manager who is in the firing line but if he doesn’t survive, how can Paul Tisdale?
“The head of football operations was at the heart of the recruitment mess in the summer. And he’s apparently the one who thought it would be a good idea to parachute a manager with a distinct way of playing into a team that doesn’t have the players to accommodate it at the most crucial stage of the season. There is no way he can remain if Nancy is sent packing.”